I enjoyed seeing the comparison at your webpage between the 170A and the new 172R. I believe the 172R cruise speed (141) is a typographical error.... but it's pretty interesting to see how favorably the 170 compares on so much less horsepower and cash outlay!
Bill Hart wrote:Awesome sorties but there are some noticeably absent………….. George?, Mile’s?
My own story of how I came to “own†(one never really "owns" artwork or airplanes....one just cares for them for a time...) N146YS, a 1953 Cessna 170-B is this:
My first airplane was a ’47 Aeronca 11AC Chief. I’d flown lots of C-120/140’s on pipeline patrol, but I have to agree with Dave Clark that the Chief was the most difficult taildragger I’ve ever flown….Especially when the rear aux tank was full of fuel and when operating in a crosswind! It was while flying pipeline patrol in the early 70's that I first came to admire the 170-B that sat at our home field owned by Will Bonaface, who I continue to run into even these days. But I digress…
After I traded the Chief for a Studebaker Starlight Coupe, I began to miss airplane ownership, and a few years later bought a Cessna 206…perhaps the most useful and one of the best all-around airplanes I’ve owned. But after six years of 206 ownership, and as much of my personal flying had become night/IFR I decided to get a twin and bought a ’62, A-55 Baron. (Later I discovered it to be the last personal airplane owned by a guy named Col. Roscoe Turner.
http://www.fiddlersgreen.net/AC/persona ... Roscoe.php )
It too was a great airplane, and I managed to lease it to a friend who used it in his personal business and still got to use it myself as well. But after 5 or 6 years of $9K to $11K annual inspections, and combined with my friend no longer needing to lease an aircraft, I decided to sell the Baron and look for something else for my personal airplane.
Our kids having grown up/moved out, Jamie and I only needed a simple airplane for personal pleasure/travel and the occasional extra seating capacity of a 4-place airplane. I’d already owned a toy airplane (the Chief), a real hauler (the 206) and the rocketship/money-burner (Baron) and felt I wanted to finally own some sort of Classic airplane. It would have to be something common enough to be able to maintain and get parts for, yet be unique enough to be “classicâ€, and still be affordable to operate out of my own pocket without too much burden. I really wanted something not too common, and yet not too odd either. I had visions of a Cessna 190/195, and …since I live on a lake, I had visions of a Republic Seabee.
A really respected older pilot and mentor (who’d flown both types extensively) helped me solve the dilemma of which type of choice to make by asking me, “George, …Just exactly what is it that you like about the Seabee… the fact that it’s a really lousy boat? … or the fact that it’s a really lousy airplane?†!!!
So I started looking for a 190/195. At the time I was flying for the state of Texas and while waiting for the atty-general over at the prison in Huntsville I saw a really pretty polished-and-yellow C-195 land and roll out. I remarked to the line boy “THAT is the kind of plane I’d like to buy!†He responded that the one landing belonged to a local airline pilot who was offering it for sale. He told me the guy’s name (Ed Bridges) and …HEY! I used to fly with that guy! He’s a great friend I’ve not seen in 15 years!
I walked up behind him as he was putting it away in the hangar and said, “What a piece of S—t! You oughta get rid of that before you embarrass yourself!†We had a big laugh and re-union and caught up on each other’s lives, and then I told him I was looking for a classic like a C-195. He said, “Well, George, I’ll be happy to sell it to you, but I really oughta let you know why I’m sellin’ it!â€
“Why? Is something wrong with it?â€, I asked.
â€Noâ€, he replied, “but,…I’ll tell you the truth… every time I come in to land it…. Just about the time I flare and it’s floating just off the pavement…. I suddenly realize I have absolutely NO IDEA what it’s gonna do! I’m going to let someone ELSE wreck it!â€
Since Ed is one of the better pilots I’ve ever known, I assumed there must be something I didn’t know about them and I passed on buying a Cessna 195. (I’ve since come to believe it was probably that particular airplane, as others have described them as fairly docile airplanes.)
Anyway, the discussion also gave me quite a bit of feel for the level of maintenance a BIG Cessna with a BIG, round, engine requires. (Hint: it results in BIG $ requirements and I’d already had that experience with the Baron.)
But that pretty, round tail, and the charisma of a conventional landing gear was still a huge attraction to me. I couldn’t help but think of the Cessna 170’s I seen throughout my early career and how I’ve always thought of them as good-looking, solid airplanes with reasonable operating costs and relatively simple maintenance issues. HEY! That’s it! Like a baby-190/195 without the expense!
I started looking. But I’d already had airplanes that needed real work to bring them back into condition and that needed continuous care to keep them that way (the Baron.) I decided that if I kept my airplane wishes simple enough, I perhaps might find an airplane in good enough condition I could be proud of it and enjoy it without it nickel-and-diming me until the pleasure was gone. I decided to look for the best-condition airplane I could find. In the late 90’s, I felt that the money I’d cleared after selling the Baron should allow me to pick a pretty fine Cessna 170 and have enough left over to build a hangar for it on the property I already owned.
I found one highly promoted on the Internet for an outrageous asking price (just reduced!) of $60K! It was very nicely promoted with pretty pics and text about favorable mods yet supposedly still very original and had been judged and given awards at Oshkosh and Sun-N-Fun, yadda-yadda-yadda....
But $60K was just too dang much money in the late 90’s for an airplane as simple as a 170 I thought. At that time, I felt that a good clean 170 should sell for high $20's to mid $30's. I couldn't imagine an old 170 with an original engine worth that kind of money, regardless of HOW much time and restoration effort had been put into it.
I continued looking around.
One day, while on another trip with the atty-general to the FTW area, with my copilot (his first day at work with the state) .. we borrowed the crew-car and went looking for breakfast. We came up on a small runway in the sticks with a restaurant on the field, and while driving down the hangar row towards the café, I noticed a polished and red 170B sitting in a hangar with a For Sale banner on it’s prop. I stopped the car and my new-hire copilot followed me into the hangar to look at it. As I got closer I suddenly realized it was the one I’d seen on the Internet. The hangar-keeper came out of his office and offered to show it to me. He was a friend of the owner, who’d just gotten an offer from a potential buyer on the plane.
As I looked the plane over, I quickly came to the realization that this airplane was very much like one which might have just rolled off the assembly-line in Kansas back in 1953. It was like NEW. New plumbing, wiring, hoses, pulleys, cables, glass, radios, instruments, panel, professionally-upholstered/completed interior (with original style and pattern-stitched fabrics, leather trim, wool carpet, wool headliner), paint/polish, tires, lights, screws, rivets….a new engine. New mount. New prop. All new exhaust. It had the P-ponk gearbox mod, new Cleveland wheels/brakes, original (new) metal wheel pants. BAS tail pull handles.You could eat off the floor beneath the carpet and also beneath the floor in the belly. The thing was entirely marinized with epoxy poliamide primer. It had no used parts on it that could be determined other than the datatag. All the controls had been reskinned and the wing re-jigged, disassembled, marinized, and then reskinned also. It was truly an all NEW Cessna 170-B.
The hangarkeeper then brought out two photo-albums documenting over 16 years of restoration work performed by it’s Bell Helicopter employee/owner. (Bell’s mfr’g plant is in the FTW area.) Suddenly it made sense why the guy thought the thing was worth so much money. It was a 16-year restoration effort of such quality as to make it a TOTALLY NEW 170-B! ALL new! Every bolt, nut, washer was bright cad-plated new! It was pretty amazing to see it in person.
I mentally balanced my checkbook and realized I had $55K available for an airplane with the rest reserved for a hangar, and that this airplane really, truly, probably WAS worth $60K! Maybe more!
I asked the guy, “How much is the seller considering from the potential buyer?â€
I nearly choked on my own racing heart when he replied, “$42K.†I think I went into arrhythmia and did my best to maintain a calm demeanor. “What’s the least you think he’d actually take for it?â€, I queried with my best attempt at a bored-sounding voice.
“Well, his wife and he have to close on a house next week and he needs $40K for a down payment…. I’d imagine Forty-THREE $K would sound better to him than $42K!â€, he replied.
I said, “Well, call him up and tell him you’ve got a guy standing here that’ll pay him $43K for it right now if he’ll sign off a new annual inspection.†(I could plainly see it didn’t need an actual annual inspection, having been judged recently and so clearly in the pristine condition it was in…but you guys know how I am!)
Remember that I was doing my best at keeping my composure throughout this ordeal and letting no one know I was already familiar with the history of this plane. ( Imagine the viewpoint of my copilot, a new state employee on his first day at work, ...and on his first leg of his first flight he sees his captain seemingly stroll into a hangar and after a few minutes of casual conversation, write a check for an airplane, and then turn to leave for breakfast at the local cafe.)
Well, the seller took me up on the offer, and I paid him additional to install Whelen strobes on the wingtips. The seller threw in the presentation materials he’d developed for Oshkosh/SunNFun and the winner’s letters so it can be parked in the winner’s circle at those events. And the copies of the magazines where it was the cover-airplane and the feature article. (May '97, Cessna Owner) And a few boxes of spare parts he'd acquired as he spent years trading/dealing for 170 parts.
The most expensive annual I’ve ever had on the plane in the 7 years I’ve owned it was $275 when it got new spark plugs. Like any airplane, there’s a few small things I feel it still needs, but…. It’s generally pretty nice to be flying a new plane! Especially a classic like a 170!
And that’s my story.